Fighting for a Free Future is pleased to welcome you back to the third edition of a new series for Voices for a Free Future: Language Against Liberty. In her monthly column, Fighting for a Free Future Volunteer Associate Jennifer Holly will be exposing the ideology hidden behind terms we use every day and how harmful they are to the fight for freedom.
When you enter into a contract, whether it be with your employer or your phone provider, you expect certain things: that the terms are clearly spelt out to you, that you have the free choice to sign it, that the other party will deliver you something you value, and that they cannot simply change the terms at whim. These rights have long been enshrined in the law - but when politicians speak of multitudes of new “social contracts”, they bear little resemblance to the nature of contracts as we understand them.
The “social contract” is a metaphor, and metaphors have consequences. If the state promises a “new social contract” with its citizens, it implies reciprocity and an obligation to pay up, without adopting the conditions that would make such a contract binding.
Locke’s conception of the social contract saw the government as strictly limited. His “tacit consent” by enjoyment of the state’s protection does not naturally extend to anything the state could provide - a civil society is formed by the surrender of the sole power of wielding the force of the law. Hume looked at ends, rather than the abstract “signing up” to an ill-defined agreement; government is accepted insofar as it is useful to its citizens. There is no agreement that pre-ordains how the government and its citizens should interact. There is also a hint of absurdity in the “signing” of this “contract”; when asked whether a poor man consents by staying within a country’s borders, Hume, in The Original Contract, replied: “we may as well assert that a man, by remaining in a vessel, freely consents to the dominion of the master; though he was carried on board while asleep”. Many of us, even if we enjoy the basic protections of government, are taken advantage of while we are “asleep”; the state forces us onto a ship sinking under the burden of ever-increasing additions to a “contract” we could never even sign in the first place.
At Labour Party Conference, Burnham promised “a new social contract for the 21st century”, which somehow meant, primarily, a tax-funded National Care Service, projected to cost around £18.5 billion extra a year by 20235/6. As with any of these new schemes, we must ask: who is going to pay? The future generations Locke said would enjoy the protections of the state are now roped into paying an obligation dictated by a “contract” that, if they did have a say in, they would never accept.
The idea of a “social contract” should not, however, be entirely disparaged. The basic philosophical idea - which may be better treated as a thought experiment - that the tacit consent of all individuals to a social arrangement makes that arrangement “just” or “legitimate” has been essential to the understanding of the interaction between government and individuals. The idea of “obligation” can also be helpful in a policy context; viewed carefully, the idea of the “social contract” can help a government remain cognisant of what it owes its citizens. What is deeply unfortunate, however, is when this idea of “obligation” is contorted; usually to the benefit of a politician wishing to dress a new draining of individuals’ pockets in a garb of moral necessity. Instead, we should return to what a government does owe its citizens, in Locke’s terms: the protection of life, liberty, and property.
Jennifer Holly is a student at Magdalen College, University of Oxford. She is a Fighting for a Free Future Volunteer Associate and is committed to the fight for free markets and civil liberties. She can be followed on X at @jenniferaholly.




Thank you Jennifer for reminding us that these so called social contracts usually come with a hefty price tag. They say that Andy Burnham wants to take us back to the 70's. Well, the labour Govt of that time introduced a social contract - handing more power to the unions, more spending on welfare, rent and price controls. It didn't end well, although thankfully we had a silver lining in Mrs T to clear up the mess and deliver a new era of prosperity.
With best wishes and keep on publishing.
Jennifer, should we now not add to Locke's terms; the protection of life, liberty and property, the overrider; kind ,fair, and reasonable?